Regular Plush Toys

(430)

Pet Knows Best Huggie Pup

$31.99 with

$39.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(168)

Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(168)

Kraft Oscar Mayer Hot Dogs Plush Dog Toys 2-Pack

$7.99 with

$9.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(39)

Bite Force Kevlar T-Rex Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.7(26)

WOOF® Rope Neck Alligator Plush Pet Toy

$7.19 with

$8.99 Sale$14.99 Orig.

Bite Force Durable Plush Mallard Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.1(65)

Mondelez International Sour Patch Dog Toy

$7.99 with

$9.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.0(23)

Bite Force Durable Plush Octopus Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.8(22)

Bite Force Durable Plush Turtle Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.9(63)

Multipet Lamb Chop Cat Toy

$5.59 with

$6.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.0(24)

Bite Force Durable Plush Hippo Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.6(27)

Top Rated

Multipet Swingin' Slevin Duck Plush Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.9(15)

Multipet 8 in Highland Cow Dog Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.2(36)

Multipet Swingin' Slevin Cow Plush Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(34)

WOOF® 3-Pack Jellyfish Coral Dog Plush

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

4.7(6)

Bite Force Durable Creepy Bear Plush Pet Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(7)

Kraft Heinz Tomato Ketchup Plush Dog Toy

$5.59 with

$6.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(18)

Catstages Purr Pillow Kitty Plush Cat Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(1)

WOOF® Fruit Soda Can Plush Pet Toy 3-Pack

$7.19 with

$8.99 Sale$14.99 Orig.

1.0(1)

Multipet Lamb Chop with Watermelon Plush Squeaker Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

3.7(3)

Bite Force Durable Cow Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

2.8(5)

Kraft 8 in Kool-Aid Man Plush Dog Toy

$7.99 with

$9.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(26)

SmartyKat Madcap Mania Mouse, Refillable Plush Catnip Cat Toy with Catnip Tube

$5.59 with

$6.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.2(5)

WOOF® 2 pc Skippy Jar Toast Plush Pet Toy

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

5.0(1)

Disney/Pixar's Finding Nemo Plush Squeaker & Crinkle Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.8(6)

WOOF® Trout Plush Dog Toy

$5.03 with

$6.29 Sale$8.99 Orig.

WOOF® Squeaky Pencil Plush Pet Toy

$5.59 with

$6.99 Sale$9.99 Orig.

5.0(1)

Playology Plush Highland Cow Beef Scent Large Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(33)

WOOF® Jumbo Octopus Plush Pet Toy

$9.59 with

$11.99 Sale$19.99 Orig.

3.7(3)

Claussen Pickles 2 Pack Dog Toys

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(12)

Top Rated

BARK Lil Squirts Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

5.0(22)

WOOF® Boat & Shark Burrow Plush Pet Toy 4-Pack

$9.59 with

$11.99 Sale$19.99 Orig.

4.0(1)

WOOF® Lobster Rope Plush Pet Toy

$6.23 with

$7.79 Sale$12.99 Orig.

3.8(5)

Disney's Winnie the Pooh 12 in Tigger on Rope Branch Plush Squeaker Pet Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(5)

Mondelēz International Teddy Grahams Plush Multi-Squeaker Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(11)

Top Rated

A1 Steak Sauce & Steak 2 Pack Plush Dog Toys

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.9(10)

BARK Stevie Sea Turtle Plush Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

5.0(2)

Friends: 10" Pivot Couch Plush Squeak Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(26)

BARK Ice Cream Cone Plush Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

Catstages Interactive Squish Prey Caterpillar Plush Cat Toy

$7.19 with

$8.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.0(1)

Petlou Easter Natural Bunny Dog Toy - 15"

$28.69

5.0(1)

Multipet 18-Inch Crimpy Pals Rabbit Plush Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(11)

BARK Consuela The Cactus Plush Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.7(27)

BARK Koalnival Barker Plush Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

Top Rated

BARK Yippy & Skippy Slippies Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(21)

WOOF® Rope Football Plush Pet Toy

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

Multipet Duckworth Plush Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(24)

BARK Humbert The Dragon Plush Pet Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(3)

Multipet Americana Highland Cow Plush Squeaker & Crinkle Dog Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

4.5(2)

BARK Moe The Mosaic Crab Plush Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

3.0(1)

Meow 2 pc Catnip Plush Toy Pack

$3.91 with

$4.89 Sale$6.99 Orig.

Catstages Loaf Kicker Cat Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(27)

Disney's 101 Dalmatians Plush Squeaker Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(4)

Outward Hound Squeaker Ballz 4 pk Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.0(101)

Star Wars: 9 in Mandalorian "The Child" Plush Figure Dog Toy with Squeaker

$19.99 with

$24.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(69)

WOOF® Disney's Stitch Hawaiian Plush Pet Toy

$9.59 with

$11.99 Sale$19.99 Orig.

5.0(1)

Harry Potter: House Sorting Hat Burrow Pet Toy

$21.59 with

$26.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.7(34)

Multipet 18" Kohl's Cash Loofa Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Orig.

BOGO 50% Off

3.9(8)

Marvel Hulk Pet Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.9(13)

SmartyKat Skitter Critters 10 pc Value Pack Plush Mouse Catnip Cat Toys

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(8)

Playology Plush Hen Chicken Scent Medium Pet Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(28)

WOOF® Plush Goose Dog Toy

$5.03 with

$6.29 Sale$8.99 Orig.

1.0(1)

Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Plush Cat Toy

$7.99 with

$9.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(2)

BARK Sasquatch Josh Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(6)

Disney's Winnie The Pooh 9 in Pooh Plush Squeaker Pet Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(7)

Harry Potter 14 in Nimbus 2000 Rope Toy with Plush Squeaker

$19.99 with

$24.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(7)

BARK Odd Otto Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(27)

Disney's Lilo & Stitch 9 in Stitch Plush Squeaker Pet Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.7(10)

Play-Doh Plush Octopus Pet Toy

$15.19 with

$18.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(4)

Disney's Woody Plush Pet Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

BARK Uncle Duck Dog Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

WOOF® Game Day Hotdog Plush Pet Toy

$5.59 with

$6.99 Sale$9.99 Orig.

Disney's Winnie the Pooh Piglet Figure Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.8(4)

WOOF® Skippy PB Jar Plush Dog Toy With 5 Squeakers

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

BARK Cup Of Bark Roast Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(3)

WOOF® Water Bottle Rope Plush Pet Toy

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

Hungry Hippo Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

$15.19 with

$18.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.7(3)

Meow 2 pc Milk & Juice Catnip Plush Toy Pack

$3.91 with

$4.89 Sale$6.99 Orig.

HORMEL® Skippy Plush Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

Midlee Snowball Fight Plush Dog Toy - 3"

$28.69

Nascar Rubber Steering Wheel Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

BARK Plush Pizza Walrus Pet Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.7(3)

Catstages Refillable Beta Fish Plush Cat Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

PetSafe® Cheese Automatic Cat Toy

$42.39 with

$52.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.5(34)

Bite Force Durable Plush Ghost Dog Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Orig.

BOGO 50% Off

3.8(18)

Playology Plush Large Pig Pork Sausage Pet Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(30)

Disney's 101 Dalmatians Bone Squeaker Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(2)

Catstages 3-Pack Plush Strawbabies Cat Toys

$7.99 with

$9.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

YEVYO Flying Bird Cat Toy, Interactive Motion Toy with Real Feathers, Enrichment Play for Indoor Cat

$17.99 $19.99

Catstages Squish Prey Interactive Squid Plush Cat Toy

$7.19 with

$8.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(10)

BARK Sesame Street Elmo Plush Pet Toy

$15.19 with

$18.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.4(5)

Outward Hound Fire Biterz Lizard Toy

$19.99 with

$24.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.5(23)

Harry Potter: Snitch Pet Squeaker Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.7(29)

Petlou Huge Durable Plush Multi-squeaks Easter Dog Toy - 29" Carrot

$33.09

Mr. Potato Head Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

$15.19 with

$18.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(6)

Peanuts Woodstock Plush Dog Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

Outward Hound Invincibles Snake Toy

$19.99 with

$24.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.2(44)

WOOF® Foam Finger Plush Pet Toy

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

Meow 2 pk Pattern Mice Plush Cat Toys

$4.31 with

$5.39 Sale$8.99 Orig.

Outward Hound Tough Skinz Woodland Hedgie Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.0(5)

BARK Bold Eagle Pet Toy

$8.15 with

$10.19 Sale$16.99 Orig.

2.0(2)

Bite Force Plush Skeleton Pet Toy

$15.99 with

$19.99 Orig.

BOGO 50% Off

4.3(7)

WOOF® Treat Calculator Plush Pet Toy

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

Plush Blanket Squeaky Dog Toy

$52.52 $58.36

Catstages Catnip Butterfly & Firefly Plush Cat Toys 2-Pack

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

Operation Squeaky Plush Toy with Rope

$15.19 with

$18.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.2(5)

Disney's The Lion King 9 in Simba Plush Squeaker Pet Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(2)

WOOF® Skippy BananaToast Plush Dog Toy

$7.27 with

$9.09 Sale$12.99 Orig.

Outward Hound Tough Skinz Woodland Owl Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(1)

Disney's Buzz Lightyear Plush Pet Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(1)

Disney's 2-Pack Woody & Jessie Plush Dog Toys

$15.99 with

$19.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(1)

Nascar Ballistic Logo Bone Dog Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

Disney's Minnie Mouse Plush Head Flat Body Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.6(8)

U.S. Soccer Panda Referee Plush Dog Toy

$7.99 with

$9.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.0(1)

Peanuts Snoopy Latex on House Pet Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

Disney's Mickey Mouse Plush Head Flat Body Dog Toy

$10.39 with

$12.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

4.5(8)

Peanuts Snoopy Multi-Squeaker Plush Dog Toy

$13.59 with

$16.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(1)

Peanuts Snoopy Latex Pet Toy

$11.99 with

$14.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

5.0(1)

Outward Hound Tough Skinz Baseball Dog Toy

$7.19 with

$8.99 Reg.

BOGO 50% Off

3.0(4)

4 pc Dog Birthday Kit: Bandana, Hat, Bow Tie, Plush Toy

$26.99

of 4

Regular Plush Toys

Change Pickup Store

All Filters (2)